SOEs Earnings and Challenges in Pakistan
Introduction
Pakistan’s state-owned enterprises (SOEs) have shown significant improvements in the first half of the fiscal year 2023-2024. These public sector companies collectively earned Rs102 billion in profits, a notable achievement in the nation’s economic landscape. However, while several SOEs demonstrated profitability, power distribution companies and Pakistan International Airlines (PIA) continued to remain financial burdens.
This article delves into the performance of SOEs, the issues surrounding their profitability, the role of privatization, and the ongoing challenges that affect their long-term sustainability.
SOEs Performance Overview: Profits and Losses
Profits Surpass Losses: A Record Achievement
In a breakthrough for Pakistan’s public sector, SOEs recorded Rs102 billion in net profit during the first half of the fiscal year. This is the first time these enterprises have achieved such results, according to the Cabinet Committee on State-Owned Enterprises (CCoSOEs). The profits are primarily attributed to the positive financial performance of several large state-run companies, with a notable contribution from the Pakistan Sovereign Wealth Fund.
Despite the good news, the financial struggles of several key entities, including PIA and power distribution companies, continue to plague the sector.
Financial Performance of SOEs
According to the report approved by the CCoSOEs, the combined revenues of the SOEs increased by over 15% compared to the same period last year, reaching a total of Rs7 trillion. This resulted in a net profit of Rs101.5 billion, a remarkable turnaround from the Rs101 billion losses experienced during the same period last year.
However, not all SOEs shared in this success. The government provided fiscal support amounting to Rs437 billion to struggling enterprises, yet the negative cash flow from loss-making entities like PIA and the National Highway Authority (NHA) remains a concern.
Challenges in Privatization and Its Effectiveness
Privatization: A Failed Strategy?
Despite over two decades of privatization efforts, several state-owned enterprises, such as Pakistan Telecommunication Limited (PTCL), continue to underperform financially. The finance ministry’s report highlighted PTCL’s loss of Rs7.8 billion during the period under review, which raised questions about the efficacy of privatization policies.
One of the key criticisms of the privatization process is the failure to significantly improve the financial viability of privatized companies. PTCL’s performance is often cited as evidence that privatization alone cannot solve the underlying issues of mismanagement, inefficiency, and lack of accountability in SOEs.
Sectoral Breakdown: The Loss Leaders
Power Distribution Companies: A Persistent Drain
The power sector remains a significant concern, with seven out of the top 15 loss-making entities being in this sector. The National Highway Authority (NHA) recorded the highest losses, amounting to Rs151.4 billion, followed by Quetta Electricity Supply Company with Rs56.3 billion in losses. PIA also continued to face massive financial difficulties, incurring losses of Rs51.8 billion during the same period.
Other loss-making entities in the power sector include:
- Peshawar Electricity Supply Company – Rs39 billion loss
- Pakistan Railways – Rs23.6 billion loss
- Sukkur Electricity Company – Rs21 billion loss
- Pakistan Steel Mills – Rs14.4 billion loss
- Islamabad Electricity Supply Company – Rs12.2 billion loss
Despite these challenges, the government continues to offer significant fiscal support to these loss-making entities, which raises concerns about the long-term sustainability of such financial bailouts.
Top Profit-Making SOEs: The Success Stories
Oil and Gas Development Company Leads the Way
Despite the struggles faced by certain sectors, several state-owned companies have posted impressive profits. Leading the way is the Oil and Gas Development Company (OGDC), which recorded Rs123.3 billion in profits. Other notable profit-making companies include:
- Pakistan Petroleum Limited – Rs68.8 billion
- National Power Parks Management Company – Rs36.3 billion
- Pak-Arab Refinery Company – Rs35 billion
- Government Holdings Company Limited – Rs32.5 billion
- Lahore Electricity Supply Company – Rs28.4 billion
- National Bank of Pakistan – Rs26.7 billion
These companies contributed significantly to the overall profits of SOEs and are often seen as models of efficiency in the public sector.
Challenges in Enhancing Efficiency
Accounting Profits vs. Cash Flow
One of the major issues with the profitability of SOEs is the reliance on accounting profits rather than actual cash flow generation. Several entities have reported high profits, but their balance sheets show significant risks in the form of high receivables and low liquidity. The government and CCoSOEs have emphasized the need for better management to turn these accounting gains into real cash flow.
Government’s Role and Strategy Moving Forward
Fiscal Support and Long-Term Solutions
The government’s strategy of providing fiscal support to SOEs has shown mixed results. Although SOEs recorded an overall positive cash flow of Rs122 billion, the persistent losses in certain sectors highlight the need for more targeted and sustainable reforms.
The CCoSOEs has suggested the need for appointing independent directors and developing realistic business plans to improve SOE performance. Additionally, the categorization of SOEs into strategic and non-strategic entities will play a crucial role in determining the potential for privatization.
The Future of State-Owned Enterprises
Privatization or Reform?
As the government seeks to streamline its fiscal policies, the question of privatization remains a contentious issue. While some SOEs have demonstrated profitability, others, like the power sector and PIA, continue to be major liabilities. The government is looking into reforms that might include strategic privatization, with an emphasis on improving the overall management and efficiency of SOEs.
FAQs
1. What is the current financial performance of Pakistan’s SOEs?
The first half of the fiscal year 2023-2024 saw Pakistan’s SOEs earning Rs102 billion in net profits, a significant improvement over the previous year’s losses.
2. Which sectors contributed the most to the profits of SOEs?
The oil and gas sector, particularly the Oil and Gas Development Company and Pakistan Petroleum Limited, contributed significantly to the profits, along with the power sector.
3. What are the major loss-making entities among SOEs?
The National Highway Authority, Quetta Electricity Supply Company, and Pakistan International Airlines are among the top loss-making entities, along with several power distribution companies.
4. Why has privatization been ineffective in Pakistan?
Despite efforts to privatize several SOEs, such as PTCL, the privatization process has not significantly improved financial performance, mainly due to continued mismanagement and lack of accountability.
5. What steps is the government taking to improve SOE performance?
The government is focusing on appointing independent directors, creating realistic business plans, and categorizing SOEs for potential privatization to improve efficiency and profitability.
Conclusion
The performance of Pakistan’s state-owned enterprises presents a mixed picture of progress and setbacks. While some entities have managed to achieve profitability, others continue to struggle with mounting losses. Privatization remains a controversial topic, with many questioning its effectiveness in addressing the systemic issues of SOEs. Moving forward, strategic reforms and a focus on efficiency will be critical in determining the future of Pakistan’s SOE sector.
MUST READ:
https://skipper.pk/2024/12/05/imf-condition-dollar-overvaluation-pakistan/
