Open Skies Policy Behind PIA’s Decline: A Detailed Analysis
Introduction
The downfall of Pakistan International Airlines (PIA) has been a topic of concern for years. A recent parliamentary fact-finding committee has identified the Open Skies Policy as a primary reason for PIA’s decline. The policy allowed Gulf airlines to expand their operations in Pakistan, leading to a loss of market share for the national carrier. Combined with poor management, financial constraints, and policy loopholes, PIA’s operations have suffered immensely.
Impact of the Open Skies Policy on PIA
What is the Open Skies Policy?
The Open Skies Policy was introduced to enhance competition, provide better services to passengers, and improve connectivity. However, in the case of Pakistan, it backfired by allowing foreign airlines to dominate the market.
Market Share Decline
According to the fact-finding report presented to the National Assembly Standing Committee on Privatisation, PIA’s market share dropped from 50% to 20% due to the influx of international carriers, particularly those from the Gulf region.
Sixth Freedom Rights and Gulf Airlines’ Expansion
One major concern is the misuse of sixth freedom rights, allowing Gulf airlines to carry passengers beyond their intended destinations. These airlines, with state-backed financial support, operated an overwhelming number of flights, which significantly impacted PIA’s international routes. Currently, international airlines conduct over 100 flights per week to and from Pakistan, making it nearly impossible for PIA to compete.
Other Factors Contributing to PIA’s Decline
Constant Leadership Changes
Frequent management changes have further weakened the airline. The appointment of inexperienced individuals in key positions has led to inconsistent policies, poor decision-making, and ineffective business strategies.
Financial Constraints and Liabilities
The report highlighted that PIA’s liabilities have exceeded Rs 740 billion, covering vendor payments, fuel charges, and government-backed loans. This financial burden has made it difficult for the airline to expand its fleet or improve service quality.
Aging Fleet and High Taxes
One of the major obstacles to PIA’s recovery is its outdated fleet. Out of 32 aircraft, only 19 are currently operational. High taxes on fleet expansion and maintenance have further restricted PIA’s ability to modernize its operations.
Privatisation Attempts and Failure
The government attempted to privatize PIA but failed. The Privatisation Commission paid $4.3 million to Ernst & Young as financial advisors, and an additional $2.6 million is expected to be paid. However, a clear strategy for the airline’s privatisation is still missing.
Financial Losses Due to Mismanagement
Golden Handshake Policy
The committee found that the Golden Handshake Policy resulted in the layoff of around 3,000 employees, including highly skilled engineers and technical staff, many of whom were later recruited by competitor airlines.
Premier Service Failure
PIA launched Premier Service for Islamabad to London flights using wet-leased aircraft, despite feasibility reports predicting losses. The project ultimately resulted in Rs 2.9 billion in total losses, including Rs 1.1 billion in operational costs.
Ban by EASA and Pilot License Controversy
The fact-finding report also blamed former Aviation Minister Chaudhry Ghulam Sarwar for making a controversial statement about pilot licenses, leading to a ban by the European Union Aviation Safety Agency (EASA). This move cost PIA an estimated $600 million in revenue over four years.
Recommendations by the Fact-Finding Committee
1. Revising the Open Skies Policy
The committee recommended that the government review, renegotiate, and reconsider the Open Skies Policy to create a fair competitive environment for PIA.
2. Financial Restructuring
A structured financial support model should be implemented, similar to international carriers that receive subsidies and tax exemptions from their governments.
3. Fleet Expansion and Modernization
Investing in new aircraft and revising taxation policies on fleet expansion is essential to make PIA competitive once again.
4. Leadership Stability and Transparency
To ensure stability, experienced professionals should be appointed in key positions, and transparent governance policies must be established.
5. Inquiry Commission on Pilot License Controversy
The committee has urged the government to set up an Inquiry Commission to investigate the former Aviation Minister’s statement, which caused reputational and financial damage to PIA.
Conclusion
PIA’s decline is a result of multiple factors, with the Open Skies Policy playing a significant role. Gulf airlines’ expansion, mismanagement, financial instability, and policy loopholes have contributed to the national carrier’s downfall. Immediate policy revisions, fleet expansion, financial restructuring, and leadership stability are necessary to revive PIA and restore its competitiveness in the aviation sector.
FAQs
1. How did the Open Skies Policy affect PIA?
The policy allowed international airlines, particularly Gulf carriers, to expand their operations in Pakistan, reducing PIA’s market share from 50% to 20% and making it difficult for the airline to compete.
2. What financial issues is PIA currently facing?
PIA’s liabilities have exceeded Rs 740 billion, including vendor dues, fuel charges, and government-backed loans. Additionally, the airline is struggling with high operational costs and outdated aircraft.
3. What role did the former Aviation Minister play in PIA’s decline?
A statement by the former Aviation Minister regarding pilot license fraud led to a ban by EASA, resulting in $600 million in revenue losses for PIA over four years.
4. How many aircraft does PIA currently operate?
Out of a total of 32 aircraft, only 19 are operational, while the rest remain grounded due to financial constraints.
5. What recommendations were made to revive PIA?
The committee suggested revising the Open Skies Policy, investing in fleet expansion, restructuring finances, ensuring leadership stability, and setting up an Inquiry Commission to investigate the former Aviation Minister’s controversial statement.
MUST READ
https://skipper.pk/2025/02/26/fto-orders-sales-tax-solar-net-metering/
