Managing Public Debt: Prudently Using the New Window
Introduction
Managing public debt effectively is crucial for economic stability. With Pakistan under an International Monetary Fund (IMF) program, there is a significant opportunity to examine debt restructuring proposals seriously. This article delves into insights shared by experts and the recent developments impacting Pakistan’s public debt scenario.
Insights on Sovereign Debt
“Like people and companies, sovereigns can struggle to repay their debt. This could be because they borrowed too much or in a way that was too risky – or because they were hit by an unexpected shock, such as a deep recession or a natural disaster. In these circumstances, the sovereign needs to restructure its debt.” These insights from S Ali Abbas and Alex Pienkowski, editors of “Sovereign Debt: A Guide for Economists and Practitioners,” highlight the importance of debt restructuring in maintaining economic stability.
Current Debt Scenario in Pakistan
Public Debt Crisis
Despite official claims to the contrary, Pakistan is indeed facing a public debt crisis. The debt-to-GDP ratio stands at 71.8%, which is not alarming by global standards. However, the debt repayment percentage of total revenue has exceeded 60%, indicating a severe fiscal strain. This high repayment rate highlights the critical need for effective debt management and restructuring.
Debt Sustainability Framework
The IMF’s new sovereign debt framework emphasizes that public debt can be considered sustainable when the primary balance needed to stabilize debt is both economically and politically feasible. Economic feasibility implies the government’s capacity to spend on productivity improvements while making debt repayments. Political feasibility means that the measures taken should not lead to social unrest.
Economic and Political Feasibility
Economic Growth Prospects
For debt sustainability, it is crucial to focus on economic growth. Growth increases earnings and government revenue, enabling better debt management. A comprehensive public expenditure management plan is essential to achieve this.
Public Expenditure Management
Former Finance Minister Dr. Aisha Ghaus Pasha points out that Pakistan’s tax-to-GDP ratio has remained almost constant over the past 20 years, while public expenditure-to-GDP has increased by 50%. In the first phase, drastic expenditure cuts are necessary to improve fiscal health without overburdening taxpayers or increasing borrowing.
The IMF Program: An Opportunity for Debt Restructuring
Structured Debt Negotiations
The current IMF program provides an opportunity to negotiate with domestic and external creditors for a formal debt restructuring schedule. This approach is more beneficial than seeking transaction-based rollovers and allows for better allocation of resources towards human development and essential infrastructure.
Reducing Mini-Budgets
A well-structured debt program will reduce the need for mini-budgets by setting more realistic tax revenue targets. The current macroeconomic framework, characterized by declining inflation and reduced discount rates, should be used as a foundation for comprehensive debt restructuring.
Debt Justice and Fiscal Responsibility
Debt Justice
The burden of debt repayment often falls on the general public, an attribution that is morally wrong. Responsibility for debt repayment should lie with government functionaries, not the public. Fiscal crises stem from government overspending, not from businesses or households.
Legislative Measures
To address this issue, penalty clauses should be added to the Fiscal Responsibility and Debt Limitations Act. Parliament should consider a constitutional amendment to enforce fiscal discipline and prevent irresponsible borrowing by the government.
Conclusion
Effective debt management is critical for Pakistan’s economic stability. By leveraging the current IMF program and focusing on structured debt negotiations, the government can ensure sustainable public debt levels. Moreover, addressing fiscal responsibility through legislative measures will help prevent future debt crises.
FAQs
1. What is the current debt-to-GDP ratio of Pakistan?
The current debt-to-GDP ratio of Pakistan is 71.8%.
2. Why is the debt repayment percentage of total revenue important?
It indicates the fiscal strain on the government. Pakistan’s debt repayment percentage has exceeded 60%, highlighting the need for effective debt management.
3. What does the IMF’s new sovereign debt framework emphasize?
The framework emphasizes that public debt is sustainable when the primary balance needed to stabilize debt is both economically and politically feasible.
4. What steps are necessary for effective public expenditure management?
Drastic expenditure cuts are necessary to improve fiscal health without overburdening taxpayers or increasing borrowing.
5. How can debt justice be achieved?
Responsibility for debt repayment should lie with government functionaries. Legislative measures, such as penalty clauses in the Fiscal Responsibility and Debt Limitations Act, should be implemented to enforce fiscal discipline.
ALSO READ:
https://skipper.pk/2024/11/11/psx-hits-new-high-as-kse-100-index-breaches-94000-barrier/
